So, i want a new shield

[Evilness45]

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

[~Axle~]

Like people are saying, Valk goes best with Toad and Maya.

1) Most useful in PvP/Woe. You might not PvP much, but it still happens. You also BG, and Toad will help more than anything.
2) There's quite a few Demi-human monsters. Most Orcs, Four MvP's, etc, etc. It's still useful for PvM.
3) Resale value. A Toad Valk will sell extremely easily compared to a Tirfing Valk. You might think you won't resell it, but plan for the future, right?

Tirfings most often go in Stone Bucklers, and overupped Guards, due to the ease of use, and relatively cheap value.

Also - It depends on your class too. If you're a Pally, maybe you want an overupped Cross shield instead of a Valk?

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

Mdef isn't all that useful for PvM. I mean - it's good to have, but reducing race or property damage works better. It's by no means a bad idea - but there might be something better out there to get first and foremost.

Edit: Also - hit me up when you plan to BG. I've been meaning to try that. I'm the bloody knight sitting next to you.

[The Mystic]

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

Get Hodremlin and maya valk's. Your all set. ;3

[Evilness45]

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

Get Hodremlin and maya valk's. Your all set. ;3

Why isnt there simply a card that reduce all damage by 124.5%?

Edit: Also - hit me up when you plan to BG. I've been meaning to try that. I'm the bloody knight sitting next to you.

I do battleground after WoE is over, like everyone else.

[The Mystic]

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

Get Hodremlin and maya valk's. Your all set. ;3

Why isnt there simply a card that reduce all damage by 124.5%?

Edit: Also - hit me up when you plan to BG. I've been meaning to try that. I'm the bloody knight sitting next to you.

I do battleground after WoE is over, like everyone else.

Because 124.5% reduction on everything for a shield card is immensely broken.

[Evilness45]

Why is maya a bad choice?

30 mdef and 18% autoguard seems nice to me

Get Hodremlin and maya valk's. Your all set. ;3

Why isnt there simply a card that reduce all damage by 124.5%?

Edit: Also - hit me up when you plan to BG. I've been meaning to try that. I'm the bloody knight sitting next to you.

I do battleground after WoE is over, like everyone else.

Because 124.5% reduction on everything for a shield card is immensely broken.

I have no idea why.

[Combo]

PVM?  Best make yourself multiple race shields then if you want good results.  If not, then Hodremlin like Mystic suggested.

[DreamerP]

I only have a Valk Toad and Alice and I keep my PvM Shield which is Tirfing in a Guard and Buckler...

[Evilness45]

PVM?  Best make yourself multiple race shields then if you want good results.  If not, then Hodremlin like Mystic suggested.

Ohh, hodremlin seems nice.

[SilentIce]

Arg, I was going to suggest Hodremlim.

[Johnsu]

Maya is the most useful choice outside of pvp/woe.

[Evilness45]

Maya is the most useful choice outside of pvp/woe.

I like to see that since it was my original choice, but some people doesn't seem to agree.

[cis_trans]

Yeah maya isn't a good choice. I could elaborate in WALLS of text, but axle summed it up nicely. Also johnsu is terrible in pvm, so never listen to him.

[Evilness45]

Yeah maya isn't a good choice. I could elaborate in WALLS of text, but axle summed it up nicely. Also johnsu is terrible in pvm, so never listen to him.

You say maya is a good choice, but then you say Axle sum it up (and he says that maya is a good choice).
Mind blown

[cis_trans]

I should refer to his post better it was one part that I liked.

Mdef isn't all that useful for PvM. I mean - it's good to have, but reducing race or property damage works better. It's by no means a bad idea - but there might be something better out there to get first and foremost.

it was this part I meant to refer to. Mdef reduction is nothing really. especially when dealing with physical damage and the plethora of armor ignoring/mdef ignoring stuff, 30 mdef versus 30% racial or 25% size reduction or even elemental reduction can be HUGE depending on what you're going up against.